fbpx
 Can you sue a manufacturer despite a warning label, and when does this apply?

When purchasing products, it’s common to see warning labels designed to inform consumers about potential risks associated with their use. However, what happens if you are injured by a product despite these warnings? Are manufacturers always protected by these labels, or are there situations where you can still sue them? This article will dive into the legal considerations surrounding warning labels and when suing a manufacturer might be a viable option.

Understanding Warning Labels

Warning labels are legally required on many products to warn consumers of potential dangers. These labels aim to provide clear and sufficient information about risks so that users can make informed decisions. For example, you might see warnings about sharp edges on tools, the dangers of ingesting certain chemicals, or the need to avoid improper use of machinery.

However, not all warning labels are created equally. Manufacturers have a legal obligation to ensure that their warnings are:

  1. Clear and Understandable: The language must be simple enough for an average consumer to comprehend.
  2. Visible: The warning must be prominently displayed where it is easily noticed.
  3. Specific: The warning must outline the risks associated with the product’s use.

Failing to meet these criteria can leave a manufacturer open to liability, even if they include a warning label.

When Can You Sue Despite a Warning Label?

There are specific scenarios where a warning label does not absolve a manufacturer from liability. Here are the main situations in which a lawsuit might be appropriate:

1. The Warning Label is Inadequate

A warning label is only effective if it properly informs consumers of the risks. If the label lacks critical information, is too vague, or uses overly technical language, the manufacturer may still be liable. For instance, a label that says, “Handle with care,” is insufficient if the product contains chemicals that could cause severe burns upon skin contact.

2. Defective Design

If a product’s design is inherently dangerous and a safer design was reasonably available, a warning label may not be enough to shield the manufacturer from liability. For example, if a power tool has exposed wiring that causes electric shocks, the manufacturer could be liable for injuries, even if a warning exists. A defective design claim argues that the product should never have been released in its current state, regardless of the label.

3. Manufacturing Defect

Sometimes, a product can have a defect due to errors in the manufacturing process, such as poor-quality materials or assembly issues. In these cases, a warning label does not excuse the manufacturer from liability. If the product differs from its intended design and causes harm, you may have grounds to sue.

4. Failure to Warn of All Known Risks

Manufacturers are required to warn consumers of all foreseeable risks associated with their product’s use. If they fail to disclose a danger they were aware of—or should have been aware of—they can be held liable. For example, if a pharmaceutical company knows a drug has severe side effects but downplays these risks on the label, they may be subject to a lawsuit.

5. Unreasonably Dangerous Products

Some products are so inherently dangerous that their risks outweigh their benefits. In such cases, the manufacturer may be held liable even with a warning label. This often applies to cases involving toxic chemicals, defective machinery, or unsafe children’s toys.

How to Determine If You Have a Case

If you’ve been injured by a product despite a warning label, several factors will determine whether you can sue the manufacturer:

  • The Nature of the Warning: Was the warning label clear, visible, and adequate?
  • The Circumstances of the Injury: Did the injury occur due to misuse, or was it a foreseeable result of using the product as intended?
  • The Defect: Was the injury caused by a design defect, manufacturing defect, or failure to warn?
  • Evidence: Documentation, photos of the product, and medical records will play a crucial role in proving your case.

An experienced personal injury lawyer can help evaluate these factors and determine the strength of your case.

Common Challenges in Suing a Manufacturer

Suing a manufacturer for product liability can be complex. Some of the common challenges include:

  • Proving Negligence: You will need to show that the manufacturer was negligent in designing, manufacturing, or labeling the product.
  • Comparative Fault: If the manufacturer argues that you misused the product, they may attempt to shift part of the blame onto you.
  • Corporate Defense Teams: Large manufacturers often have skilled legal teams to defend against claims, making it essential to have experienced legal representation.

How We Can Help

At Hayes Law, we specialize in personal injury cases and have a proven track record of taking on large manufacturers to secure justice for our clients. Jillian and Jim Hayes, the lead attorneys at our firm, have extensive experience handling product liability claims and achieving exceptional results.

If you’ve been injured by a product and are unsure whether you have a case, we’re here to guide you every step of the way. We offer free case consultations to evaluate your situation and help you understand your legal options.

Don’t let a warning label deter you from seeking the compensation you deserve. Contact Hayes Law today to discuss your case and take the first step toward justice.